A station quality-of-earnings review checks reported profit against records and tests whether it can continue. Review cash, fuel and stock costs, payroll, adjustments, related parties, and working-capital timing. Identify changes under buyer ownership and keep forecasts separate from history. Confirm the review’s scope and lender rules before using its findings for price or funding.
What question should the engagement answer?
Define the deal, earnings measure, periods, entities, and intended use before hiring the reviewer. The buyer needs to know whether acquired earnings are reliable and recurring. A report called QoE alone does not answer that. Agree on tasks, records, access, limits, and the provider’s independence and relevant experience before work begins.
The valuation hub links the review to price and funding. Define whether the buyer acquires a store, selected assets, land, or several sites. Shared costs, internal transfers, and retained work may affect acquired profit. A combined seller total is not enough when it includes income or costs outside what the buyer receives.
The SBA acquisition guidance recommends reviewing financial statements, tax returns, contracts, and leases with professional assistance. Organize those records for the financial reviewer and identify missing periods early. The provider should explain what the available evidence supports and what cannot be resolved within the agreed scope.
How are sales and cash collections reconciled?
Trace reported sales through operating records, settlements, deposits, and books using matching cutoffs. Classify receipts before adding them: loans, owner funds, transfers, and refunds differ from customer revenue. Explain timing gaps with evidence. Do not force the bank and profit report to agree with an adjustment that has no support.
Separate gross card sales from net settlements, fees, chargebacks, and delays. Check drawers, paid-outs, deposits in transit, and relevant amounts owed by customers. Timing or classification may explain a gap, but needs evidence. Keep a difference open until the reviewer identifies and supports its cause instead of assuming the accounts are correct.
| Evidence | Review question | Common limitation |
|---|---|---|
| POS and sales reports | What transactions were recorded? | Totals may include taxes, refunds, or other categories |
| Merchant statements and banks | How did collections reach cash? | Fees, timing, transfers, and financing affect deposits |
| Supplier invoices and inventory | Which costs support goods sold? | Purchases and consumption occur in different periods |
| Payroll and schedules | What labor did the operation require? | Unpaid owner or family work can obscure replacement needs |
| Tax returns and ledger | Do accounting versions reconcile? | Methods, entities, and adjustments may differ |
What makes fuel earnings different from gallons or sales?
Rebuild the earnings the operator actually keeps under its model. Find who owns fuel, sets prices, receives money, and pays costs. Dealer, commission, and supply models may report revenue differently and carry different risks. Large gallon or sales totals alone cannot show which earnings will transfer to the buyer after sale.
NACS’s fuel-profit explainer, dated February 2025, distinguishes gross markup from expenses such as delivery and card costs. Use that distinction to frame the review, not to assign its national examples to the target station. Reconcile actual invoices, settlements, rebates, allowances, and fees under the relevant contracts.
Check stock movement and cutoffs at period end. A late delivery may raise purchases without being sold that month. Ask how the stock method links gallons received, sales, tank readings, and costs. Missing explanations should remain open questions, rather than turn into assumed profit or an automatic adjustment that increases earnings.
How should inside gross profit and labor be tested?
Review sales and costs by useful category when records allow: merchandise, foodservice, lottery commissions, and other income. Different reporting can make sales look larger without increasing kept profit. Check stock, shrink, spoilage, promotions, and supplier credits. One margin percentage across all categories can hide the actual costs and contribution of each.
Inspect staffing and payroll against actual operating hours and responsibilities. Identify unpaid owner work, family assistance, overtime, management coverage, and benefits. The earnings add-back guide explains why removing compensation may require a replacement deduction. A buyer’s labor budget should support the work required under the intended ownership model.
Check unusual costs and missing expenses as well as positive adjustments. Missing bills, unpaid upkeep, low related-party charges, and omitted replacement staff can reduce supported earnings. A useful review explains both increases and decreases from a defined starting result. Its purpose is to find supported profit, rather than simply build a larger number.
How does working capital change the cash interpretation?
Separate recurring earnings from cash needed to support them. Stock, settlement delays, supplier terms, payroll dates, and unpaid bills affect operating cash. A profitable month can still use cash when stock grows or collections slow. Review normal balances and seasonal patterns before deciding the closing bank balance is enough to run the store.
Check aged bills and receivables against what transfers in the deal. State what the seller keeps, what the buyer owes, and which balances may change. Use The Closing-Day Cash Bridge to link findings to opening cash needs. Do not count the same stock or debt twice when combining the schedules.
Review overdue work and major spending separately from accounting earnings. Adding back depreciation does not pay for a failed dispenser or new roof. Separate routine operating costs, required catch-up work, and optional buyer improvements. Each affects the purchase differently and needs its own evidence and budget rather than one broad earnings adjustment.
What do current SBA QoE requirements actually cover?
Have the lender apply the current policy to the actual structure rather than using a blanket station rule. SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, defines lender-benefit QoE and Cash Proof. Appendix 15 generally requires QoE for specified Business Expansion and Initial Acquisition transactions at a defined purchase price of at least $3 million, before equity or seller-debt reductions.
The appendix treats categories differently and includes an owner-occupied Special Purpose Property exception. Lender records and other financial diligence are still required. Under the policy definition, special-purpose property has limited utility tied to its design or layout. Ask the lender whether the actual site and deal meet the rules; calling it a station is not enough.
Where required, an independent financial professional must review and reconcile statements, tax returns, internal records, and transcripts. Cash Proof checks banks against income statements and tax returns. Ask the lender about required periods, vendor review, and a report ordered by the buyer. A seller’s schedule does not automatically meet the policy.
Which findings matter beyond the reported earnings total?
Check reliance on major revenue sources, continuing contracts, pricing risks, key staff, related parties, and changes after sale. Past profit may depend on rights or relationships that do not transfer. Find evidence that the earnings can continue. Keep planned buyer changes in a separate forecast, rather than say the seller already achieved them.
The interest-rate sensitivity guide shows why corrected earnings can change repayment capacity. The earnout guide addresses future payment metrics and restrictions. Use one consistent definition where appropriate, and explain differences when financing, valuation, and contract calculations intentionally use different measures.
The IRS business-sale overview explains separate asset treatment and allocation. That tax analysis differs from earnings reliability. Coordinate the two with the exit-tax guide without presenting an asset allocation or tax return alone as proof of recurring operating cash flow.
What should the final report enable the buyer to decide?
The report should show a traceable earnings bridge, supported explanations, risks, and open questions within its scope. Separate findings from assumptions and missing evidence. Then the buyer can judge effects on price, funding, conditions, further review, or stopping. A total without its supporting bridge cannot explain which problems remain or how they affect the deal.
- Reconcile the transaction perimeter, entities, records, and reviewed periods.
- Trace sales, purchases, payroll, and cash movements with consistent cutoffs.
- Document adjustments, replacement costs, and recurring obligations.
- Assess working capital, contract continuity, and buyer-specific assumptions.
- Present findings and open issues for valuation, lender, and closing review.
Keep records and explanations behind each conclusion. Clear scope and evidence help the buyer judge the purchase and remaining unknowns. Supported earnings do not replace site, legal, operating, or financing work outside the financial review.