Evaluate a dealer-supply agreement by translating its pricing formula, volume duties, incentives, brand standards, equipment arrangements, and transfer provisions into the buyer’s operating plan. Reconcile the written terms with actual invoices and settlements. Confirm usable rights after closing and identify costs or obligations that historical earnings may not show before relying on the seller’s fuel margin.

Which documents make up the actual supply arrangement?

Read the whole contract package: amendments, schedules, incentive papers, equipment terms, guarantees, and notices. The signed base contract may not show current prices or every duty still owed. List oral understandings apart from written terms. Do not assume they can be enforced or that a summary captures the whole agreement.

Name the parties and what each does. Supplier, jobber, brand owner, landlord, and equipment owner may be separate companies. Check who delivers fuel, grants brand rights, sets standards, and approves the deal. A familiar logo on the canopy does not tell you which party controls each of those rights.

The buyer hub connects contract review with the broader acquisition. Prepare a document index showing execution dates, effective dates, expiration, notice addresses, and superseded provisions. Ask counsel to resolve conflicts and missing signatures before using a summary sheet as the basis for the financial model.

How does the pricing formula become a delivered cost?

Identify benchmark, terminal, grade, price timing, differential, freight, taxes, fees, and discounts. Rack plus alone does not state every input. Check terms for unavailable fuel, other terminals, delivery size, and changed prices or charges. The buyer needs the full formula to forecast delivered cost under the actual agreement.

OPIS describes its wholesale rack pricing products, which can provide references for supply transactions. A benchmark alone is not the station’s full delivered cost. Match the contractual reference to invoice dates and actual product, then explain differences rather than assuming a quoted market number controls every delivery.

The fuel contribution review provides the operating reconciliation. Request enough invoices to cover different periods and products, along with credits and settlements. Test the formula using quantities and terms the buyer will actually receive, including any changes required at transfer.

What does a small differential mean at the site’s volume?

Convert each cost change into dollars using supported gallons, while holding other assumptions constant. The calculation reveals sensitivity, not certainty. Sales volume, product mix, delivery pattern, and retail competition can change alongside supplier terms, so show those uncertainties separately.

Check cents versus dollars. A cost difference is not net profit; other expenses and retail-price responses still matter.

Which incentives continue for the buyer?

Separate routine credits from project funds, signing payments, conditional rebates, and other support. Check eligibility, periods, thresholds, payment dates, required spending, and repayment terms. Find whether the books show a credit in fuel cost, other income, or a separate account. Each treatment needs a bridge that counts the benefit once.

Check whether benefits continue: they may depend on the seller, a project, remaining term, or volume. Get proposed terms in writing. Willingness to discuss help is not an approved incentive schedule.

NACS explains why fuel gross margin must cover additional retailer expenses. Use that distinction when evaluating incentives. The P&L reading guide helps prevent a credit from increasing earnings twice or a required repayment from disappearing between the ledger and transaction model.

What obligations can change operating cash needs?

Check purchase duties, exclusivity, product rules, ordering, delivery access, payment timing, deposits, credit limits, and guarantees. Review remedies and cure terms with counsel. Not every agreement has all of these. Record what this one says and what needs clarification before putting the costs and duties into your operating plan.

Test duties against realistic trading: minimum purchases need a supported volume forecast. Short payment terms or less credit can need extra cash even with an attractive fuel price. A personal guarantee adds risk beyond company profit. Check those effects alongside the quoted cents-per-gallon spread.

Use a contract worksheet that shows both the obligation and the evidence needed to model it. Avoid merging all supplier-related costs into one cents-per-gallon assumption when some are fixed, conditional, or tied to a future event.

Buyer worksheet for dealer-supply agreement diligence
TermEvidence to requestBuyer-model question
Pricing and freightComplete formula, invoices and creditsWhat is matched delivered cost?
Volume and exclusivityCommitments, exceptions and remediesCan supported demand meet the duties?
Incentives and fundingEligibility, settlement and repayment schedulesWhat continues and what can be reclaimed?
Image and equipmentStandards, ownership records and project noticesWho pays and controls each asset?
Transfer and expiryConsent process, term and notice provisionsWhat usable rights exist after closing?

Who pays for brand standards and equipment changes?

List current standards, known faults, planned image work, and who pays. Check signs, canopy, pumps, payment systems, and other equipment where relevant. Ask for notices and project records. A tidy appearance does not prove brand compliance or show that the buyer will have no required spending after closing.

Check equipment owners, liens, leases, and removal rights. Items used daily may belong to the supplier or someone else. Ask whether use continues for you and whether new contracts are needed. Name who pays for repairs, replacements, and returns so the budget reflects the assets and rights you actually receive.

Separate brand standards from legal product-labeling duties. The FTC Fuel Rating Rule guidance addresses certification and posting of fuel ratings. Compliance with those duties does not itself establish brand approval, contract transfer, equipment ownership, or the buyer’s ability to operate under the seller’s complete arrangement.

What approvals establish usable rights after closing?

Check whether the deal needs consent, assignment papers, a new supply contract, or review of an ownership or control change. Ask the parties for steps, buyer details, documents, and proposed commercial changes. Coordinate these with loan and lease approvals. One approval does not automatically settle the others needed to trade.

The PMPA assignment provision in 15 USC 2806(b) does not itself authorize assignment of a franchise. Contract provisions and applicable state law matter. Counsel should evaluate coverage and transaction-specific rights; do not turn general federal franchise protections into a promise that this buyer will receive consent.

Track the required evidence through The Tank-to-Title Diligence Map. Align the proposed purchase conditions with the actual approval path. A buyer should understand what happens if consent is denied, delayed, or conditioned on terms that materially change the operating economics.

How do term and exit provisions affect the investment?

Compare fuel term with occupancy, financing, and your holding period. Review renewals, notices, termination, funding repayment, and equipment effects with counsel. Long terms may lock in unsuitable costs or duties.

Check purchase rights, first-refusal clauses, or sale restrictions actually present in this contract. Name their scope, trigger, process, and effect on the deal. Do not assume a clause applies only to an asset sale. A different deal structure does not by itself prove that the restriction goes away.

Build a worse case for expiry or required changes. Do not assume you can switch suppliers or brands at once. Check notices, approvals, work, equipment access, and lost trading time. Establish costs and feasible choices before assigning value to flexibility that the contract and site may not allow.

How should unresolved terms affect the purchase decision?

Give open terms a request, owner, deadline, and budget effect. Missing freight rates differ from refused consent, but both need attention. Label assumptions and save supporting papers so reviewers can distinguish agreed terms from pending conditions.

The acquisition diligence checklist connects supplier findings with financial, legal, environmental, and property review. Ask the deal team to reconcile the purchase agreement, supply documents, lender conditions, and operating forecast. Signing one set of documents does not cure a contradiction in another.

Before closing, confirm the effective buyer arrangement, authorized counterparties, opening deliveries, credit setup, equipment access, and outstanding funding or project obligations. Retain the final contract worksheet with its supporting records. It should explain how the buyer can operate and what the buyer must pay, rather than simply confirm that a branded station has a fuel supplier.